If you own a Frigidaire refrigerator that uses the Pure Source Ultra II filter (EPTWFU01), you already know that OEM replacements can be pricey. The ICEPURE 3-pack offers a lower-cost alternative, but does it deliver the same performance? This review examines the practical aspects of using these filters in everyday situations.
First, a bit of context: refrigerator water filters are typically changed every six months or when the filter indicator lights up. For a household of four, that means about two filters per year, making a 3-pack roughly an 18-month supply. The ICEPURE filters are designed to fit the same housing as the OEM version, so installation is straightforward—twist out the old, twist in the new. No tools required. The filters are also NSF/ANSI 42 certified for chlorine taste and odor reduction, which is the primary function most people rely on.
In terms of construction, the ICEPURE filters use a carbon block design similar to the OEM. They claim to reduce chlorine, sediment, and other impurities, but it’s important to note that they are not NSF/ANSI 53 certified for lead or other heavy metals. If your water supply has known issues with lead or other contaminants, you may want to stick with the OEM filter or a more comprehensive solution. For municipal water that meets EPA standards, the ICEPURE should be sufficient for improving taste and removing chlorine.
Real-world usage: After installing the ICEPURE filter, users often report that the water tastes clean and free of the chlorine aftertaste common with unfiltered tap water. Flow rate is generally comparable to OEM, though some users have noticed a slight decrease in water pressure, especially as the filter nears the end of its life. This is typical for carbon block filters and not unique to ICEPURE.
One limitation is that the filter housing may not be as robust as the OEM. A few users have reported that the filter can be slightly harder to twist into place, and there have been isolated cases of leaks if not seated properly. It’s crucial to follow the installation instructions and run water through the filter for a few minutes to flush out carbon fines before use. Also, while the 3-pack is convenient, storing the extra filters requires space—each filter is about the size of a large water bottle.
Compared to other aftermarket filters, such as those from Waterdrop or AmazonBasics, ICEPURE is competitively priced and offers similar performance. However, if you prioritize OEM quality and guaranteed compatibility, the genuine Frigidaire filter might be worth the extra cost. On the other hand, if you’re looking to save money without sacrificing basic filtration, ICEPURE is a reasonable choice.
Who is this for? Budget-conscious homeowners with standard water quality who want a reliable, no-frills replacement filter. It’s also suitable for rental properties where you might not want to invest in premium filters. Who is it not for? Those with well water or known contaminant issues that require NSF/ANSI 53 certification, or people who prefer the peace of mind of OEM parts.
In summary, the ICEPURE 3-pack is a practical, cost-effective option for maintaining your refrigerator’s water filter. It performs adequately for typical municipal water, though it has minor trade-offs in build quality and certification. If you’re comfortable with aftermarket parts, it’s worth considering.